It wouldn’t be Thanksgiving without her mom’s chess pie

Mary Clay Bassett, who grew up in Hopkinsville, copied her mother's chess pie recipe on an index card 44 years ago and makes it every year for the holidays.

Hoptown Chronicle asked our readers to share stories and recipes that illuminate the Thanksgiving traditions in their families. The response was tremendous. Whether you decide to try some of the recipes or you just soak up the stories, we think you’ll enjoy this series. The stories range from poignant to heart-warming to hilarious. Enjoy.

Mary Clay Bassett is part of a group we fondly refer to as the “Hoptown Expats” because they’ve become dedicated readers of Hoptown Chronicle’s Daily Scoop and Sunday Brew newsletters to keep up with the news and happenings in their old hometown.

Mary, the daughter of the lates James and Margaret Clay, grew up in Hopkinsville with her brother and three sisters. She lives now in the Carolinas. She shared a pie recipe that came from her mother.

Mary wrote, “This is my mother’s chess pie recipe that our family has loved all our lives. I copied the recipe when I was newly married in 1979, and this is the original card 44 years later. It has deceptively few and very simple ingredients, but the combination is magically delicious. I’m not sure about my brother and sisters, but in my family it is a Thanksgiving tradition. Best with homemade pie crust, of course!”

chess pie recipe
Mary Clay Bassett recorded her mom’s pie recipe on this index card in 1979. (Photo provided)

Margaret Clay’s Chess Pie

INGREDIENTS:

  • 1/2 cup melted butter
  • 1 1/2 cups sugar
  • 1 1/2 teaspoon corn meal
  • 1 1/2 teaspoon vinegar
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

INSTRUCTIONS:

  1. Mix ingredients by hand and pour into an unbaked pie shell.
  2. Bake at 325 degrees for one hour.
Hoptown Chronicle is an independent, nonprofit news outlet that is dedicated to providing fair, fact-based reporting for people who care about Hopkinsville, Kentucky. We believe that public service journalism serves the community's social, cultural and economic wellbeing by fostering knowledge, connection and meaning.